Hey everyone, thought I might try my hand at Autocad. I made a quick drawing for making center punches with 60 degree points. It's a good beginner project, I'm thinking of making a set at the shop this coming monday. Will post pictures when I get around to it. Let me know if there are issues with the pdf or if drawing specs are a problem.
Hey Booze, the drawing looks great! I haven't tried printing them, I wonder if the green will show up ok?
When you get the punches done post some pictures and I'll add this project to the front page as a beginner project. Thanks for your contribution!
NOTE: I work full time and I'm attending college full time as well. So if it takes me a few days to respond, please don't take it personally. If it's urgent please send me a Private Message.
REMEMBER: You need to subscribe to your posts so that you'll receive an e-mail update when a member replies. You can also set your profile up so that you're auto-subscribed to all your posts. To set up Auto-Subscribe go to Profile > Personal Options > Auto-Subscribe to Posts.
If you are having trouble posting pictures, be sure to visit the FAQ section of the forum for instructions.
If you are having trouble viewing the forum posts, consider trying a different browser like Firefox or Chrome.
Hey, I've made some adjustments to the drawings and have a few pictures of a first trial piece I made earlier today. I will post up progress on the actual punches shortly…
Here is the trial blank that I "attempted" to turn down to 3/8 inch. The stock material is slightly oversize at about 15/32 inch. As an aside, I really love those Aloris quick-change tool posts. This is a Hardinge lathe at the shop at my university. I was blessed with having full access to facilities there.
Here is the compound rest set up to turn a 30 degree taper. The turned rod had inconsistent finish because my speed was too low.
Here is the result of a few passes using the compound rest.
The test piece brought to a single 30 degree point. I think I'm getting the hang of this. The finish on the taper looks much better too. You'll have to excuse the marrs on the left side of the image. I got the workpiece stuck in the collet and couldn't get it out. A little impatient, I used some 'physical persuasion'. Luckily I found out later that giving the spindle lock lever a good tap will pop the 5C collet open.
Thanks for viewing. I will post up the actual center punches as they are made.
Hey Booze, I just got back from vacation and saw your post. The test piece looks great! Have you made any further progress? How do you plan to harden them once they are finished?
NOTE: I work full time and I'm attending college full time as well. So if it takes me a few days to respond, please don't take it personally. If it's urgent please send me a Private Message.
REMEMBER: You need to subscribe to your posts so that you'll receive an e-mail update when a member replies. You can also set your profile up so that you're auto-subscribed to all your posts. To set up Auto-Subscribe go to Profile > Personal Options > Auto-Subscribe to Posts.
If you are having trouble posting pictures, be sure to visit the FAQ section of the forum for instructions.
If you are having trouble viewing the forum posts, consider trying a different browser like Firefox or Chrome.
Hello again, here is a pic of the (not fully) finished center punches. The third one needs to have the second taper turned. I will have to post up the updated drawings soon.
As far as hardening goes, there was a guy on Youtube who showed you can harden drill rod using a small propane torch. I live in an apartment so I thought it would be great to go outside and get these punches hardened. Gives me the opportunity to scare some of the neighbors' kids too! The instructions for these punches came from an old Workshop Series book, the author recommends using silver steel (ie: drill rod is the closest to that, I believe), heating until it is the colour of a boiled carrot, and dipping in oil. Then you need to place it in a sand bath (no idea what that is) and temper until the metal has the colour of straw.
My only concern is what temperatures these finishes are achieved at, and how effective the torch would be at getting this work completed. The guys in the shop told me that I need to make sure it is drill rod (the material was in the drill rod rack, but unmarked so it could be something else). I think I'll use a piece of rough stock and heat it to see if it hardens. If not, the shop guys said they can get it vacuum-hardened (?) at a subcontractor. Unfortunately, I did not make the punches in such a way to allow for knurling at this point, so I will mill out some flats and punch out the size markings. Will update on how it all goes.
Very nice work, booze… 'physical persuasion'!!! ???:):) what is it about you Canadian guys??? Nick arm-wrestles polar bears and makes his own paper-clips out of 1" bar-stock, now we have you teaching that poor, defenseless lathe to release your part on demand!!! :)
Cmon guys, seriously, anything I can't solve with a heavy brass, or the copper hammer usually yields to an assortment of cursing… HINT: learn to cuss in a second language!!! :):) It may not help, but does make ya feel better… :) and nobody else knows what yer saying :):)
So how does one apply knurling to punches like there? Do you knurl BEFORE turning the tapers and points? I'd think the knurling would get damaged by the chuck… but then you DID mention 'collet', so once again [or maybe STILL], the Mammoth is clueless… knurling tooling is a month or two down the road, but definitely one of my machining dreams.
– Don 'turning perfectly usable metal into scrap and luving it!'
Hahaha, yeah I don't mind applying a little elbow grease on the job, so to speak. But for the sake of the workpiece not looking like silly putty, I will be using a gentler touch next time.
As far as knurling goes, I believe you need to turn between centers, so yes you would have to knurl before you make the tapers. The machinists I speak to say that the forces generated from knurling are so great that you should use a dead center (lubricated) in the tailstock, and a headstock that can take the punishment. I've never knurled but am planning on giving it a go in the near future.
There was a video where someone mentioned something to the effect that the diameter of the workpiece needs to be a multiple of the thread pitch of the knurling tool in order to get the even diamond pattern right (interesting quirk!).
If you want to avoid marring the knurl pattern, you could always cut up some paper or a soda can and wrap it around the part before chucking. You may need to true up the part if using a chuck, not sure how it would come up in a collet.
very nice job so far! centuries more advanced than my first project! :) with the hardening will you be able to get it hot enough with propane? i only ask because i tried hardening some drill rod with propane and i couldn't seem to get it hot enough, so i ended up using oxy-propane. ( it may have been the torch itself that i was using, it seems to be a bit of a loose flame, i guess for plumbing)
i think a sand bath is a box full of very hot sand that you can draw a temper in, because it is a more gentle heating, you can watch the temperature spreading. a kitchen oven works great for tempering small parts, you can select a temperature and taylor a hardness with surprising ease! ( just make sure there is no oil on the steel when you put it in, you next project might very well be a nice dog house! :) )
A pessimist sees the difficulty in every opportunity;
an optimist sees the opportunity in every difficulty.
RE all that Canadian 'elbow grease' , I'm thinking it must be something to do with Labatt :):)
- I'm sure I'll get a shoe thrown at my head when I say this, but I personally dislike Labatt blue. I'm more for Alexander Keiths or Guiness. But the mention of Labatt is reason enough for me to reach over for my pipe wrench, Hahaha!
Thanks for the feedback, I find matching the angle of the tapers while keeping the part's overall length to spec is pretty difficult. I kinda screwed up the lengths of the punches, but I guess a set of stubby punches would come in handy in tight corners.
I haven't tried hardening before, so this is going to be a learn-as-you-go process. I am going to try and use the torch in the shop, if not I may go out and buy a small home kit. I will check to see how hot I can get it.
Nick, do u actually have a thermocouple or something to check the temperature when hardening, or do u go by eyesight? I've read that to quench you only need to get the metal to a boiled carrot colour. But when tempering, can you immerse the part in the sand and pass the torch over the sand slowly (I dont want to infuse oily fumes into my roast chicken, as appetizing as that may be)? Does the sand change colour or would you have to pull the part out from time to time and check? Lastly, can I just use some park sand or does it need to be of some consistent quality?
Time to make me a sandbath…Come next week all the kids in the neighborhood will be going to the jungle-gym and saying 'Hey Joe, where'd all the sand go!?'